Support when it matters

How to File an Insurance Claim with Fortner

If something goes wrong, we recommend calling us first at 417-882-5560—we’ll walk you through what to expect and help you file. For after-hours emergencies, you can also contact your insurance carrier directly using the numbers and links below.

Logo of Acuity Insurance: Heart-shaped design with red and pink colors; dark gray word

Acuity

800.242.7666

Logo for American Collectors Insurance: Blue eagle design above text in blue.

American Collectors

800.360.2277

Auto-Owners Insurance logo with company name in dark blue cursive over

Auto-Owners Insurance

517.323.1200

Billing: 800.288.8740

Claims: 888.252.4626

Roadside: 888.869.2642

Barton Mutual Insurance Company logo: orange sun over green hills, small cross, blue text.

Barton Mutual

417.843.6265

Brotherhood Mutual logo with a blue church window and text.

Brotherhood Mutual

800.360.2277

Logo of Columbia Insurance Group: blue text, a silhouetted figure with a flag, white background.

Columbia Insurance Group

Claims: 888.992.5246

After Hours: 888.992.5246

Glass: 888.992.5246

Road Side Assistance: 888.992.1603

Logo for Condon Skelly, insurance company. Features green and blue graphic and text:

Condon & Skelly

800.257.9496

GEICO logo in blue block letters on a white background.

GEICO

geico.com/contact-us

GuideOne Insurance logo with a geometric design in orange, yellow, and blue above the company name.

Haulers Insurance Company

1.877.448.4331

Claims: 866.665.1003

Foremost Insurance Group logo: Blue

Foremost Insurance Group

800.532.4221

Claims: 800.527.3907

Hagerty logo in blue, stylized text on a white background.

Hagerty Insurance

877.922.9701

Claims: 800.922.4050

The Hartford logo: Burgundy stag standing on grass; text

The Hartford

860.547.5000

Claims: 800.243.5860

HICI Haulers Insurance Company logo with blue and red text and a road graphic.

Haulers Insurance Company

800.346.6071

Claims: 866.665.1003

Liberty Mutual logo with the Statue of Liberty and company name.

Liberty Mutual

Personal Insurance: 833.218.0215

Small Business: 844.325.2467

Mid to Large Business:

800-362-0000

Lititz Mutual Insurance Company logo with blue text and bird illustration.

Lititz Mutual Insurance Company

800.626.4751

Claims: 866.420.0264

Missouri Employers Mutual logo, dark blue

Missouri Employers Mutual (MEM)

800.442.0593

Gold Markel logo with three vertical rectangles of varying heights.

Markel

800.416.4364

Logo for Philadelphia Insurance Companies: A blue bell in a blue square and text to the right.

Philadelphia Insurance

1.800.765.9749

Progressive logo in blue text on a white background.

Progressive

800.776.4737

Blue

RLI Corp

800.331.4929

Safeco Insurance logo:

Safeco Insurance

800.332.3226

Selective logo with the word

Selective

800.735.3284

Claims: 866.455.9969

State Auto Insurance logo: Blue

State Auto

800.444.9950

Claims: 800.766.1853

Auto Glass Claims: 888.504.4527

Travelers Insurance logo with black text and a red umbrella icon.

Travelers

800.842.5075

Claims: 800.252.4633

Roadside Assistance: 800.252.4633

Travelers Insurance logo with black text and a red umbrella icon.

Travelers

800.842.5075

Claims: 800.252.4633

Roadside Assistance: 800.252.4633

UBIC logo in white letters on a red square.

UBIC Utah Business Insurance Co.

866.642.8242

Claims: 801.268.0195

Logo of USLI, a Berkshire Hathaway Company. Blue stylized

USLI

888.523.5545

Logo for West Bend, featuring a stylized blue and gray design and the text

West Bend

800.236.5010

Claims: 877.922.5246