Carriers

At Fortner Insurance, we’ve been working with the companies you know and trust since 1985. Take a look for yourself, and you’ll see that Fortner Insurance has the experience and expertise of the big agencies, with the one-on-one service you can only get from an insurance provider who personally cares about each and every customer.

Auto-Owners Insurance

http://www.auto-owners.com

517.323.1200

Billing: 800.288.8740

Claims: 888.252.4626

Roadside: 888.869.2642



American Collectors

http://www.americancollectors.com

800.360.2277

Claims: Select a State


American Modern

http://www.amig.com

800.543.2644



Amerisafe

http://amerisafe.com

800.897.9719

Claims: 800.699.6240


Barton Mutual

http://bartonmutualgroup.com

417.843.6265



Brotherhood Mutual

https://www.brotherhoodmutual.com

800.380.5474

Claims: 800.933.1849



Cameron Insurance Companies

http://www.cameron-insurance.com

800.326.6511

Claims: 877.226.4577


Columbia Insurance Group

https://www.colinsgrp.com

Claims: 888.992.5246

After Hours: 888.992.5246

Glass: 888.992.5246

Road Side Assistance: 888.992.1603


Condon & Skelly

http://www.condonskelly.com

800.257.9496



Electric Insurance Company

https://www.electricinsurance.com

800.342.5342

Claims: 800.227.2757

Roadside: 800.578.3543

Glass Only: 866.519.5578


FirstComp

https://www.firstcomp.com

888.500.3344



Foremost Insurance Group

http://www.foremost.com

800.532.4221

Claims: 800.527.3907


Grinnell Mutual

https://www.grinnellmutual.com

800.362.2041



Hagerty Insurance

http://www.hagerty.com

877.922.9701

Claims: 800.922.4050


The Hartford

http://www.thehartford.com

860.547.5000

Claims: 800.243.5860


Haulers Insurance Company

www.haulersinsurance.com

800.346.6071

Claims: 866.665.1003


Lititz Mutual Insurance Company

http://www.lititzmutual.com

800.626.4751

Claims: 866.420.0264


Missouri Employers Mutual (MEM)

http://www.mem-ins.com

800.442.0593



Midwest Builders’ Casualty Group

https://www.mwbc.com

800.374.7798



Nationwide Insurance

http://www.nationwide.com

877.669.6877



Old Republic

http://www.orinsco.com

800.877.0226



Progressive

http://www.progressive.com

800.776.4737



RLI Corp

http://www.rlicorp.com

800.331.4929



Safeco Insurance

http://www.safeco.com

800.332.3226



Selective

http://www.selective.com

800.735.3284

Claims: 866.455.9969


State Auto

http://www.stateauto.com

800.444.9950

Claims: 800.766.1853

Auto Glass Claims: 888.504.4527


Travelers

https://www.travelers.com

800.842.5075

Claims: 800.252.4633

Roadside Assistance: 800.252.4633


UBIC Utah Business Insurance Co.

https://utahbic.com

866.642.8242

Claims: 801.268.0195


USLI

http://www.usli.com

888.523.5545



West Bend

http://www.thesilverlining.com

800.236.5010

Claims: 877.922.5246